Thrilled to see Masterharper gets a mention ...

[Jane]

:geek:

http://www.wired.com/geekdad/2009/08/5- ... n-written/

[Amanda N]

Am I the only one who liked that book?

[Jane]

You're the only one who liked it out of you, me and the person who wrote the article, that's for sure.  :geek:

[Amanda N]

I don't think anyone else here liked it either.  I think most people hated it.  I liked it.  Of course, I read it years and years after I did the other books, so maybe that's why.

[Paula]

Hey! I thought it was okay, not as good as some but enjoyable reading anyway. The was most irritating was the end-part of the book. (Did she _have to_ place Robinton to Ruatha when Lessa was Searched?)

[Cali]

When canon doesn't match I just go "yuck".  I don't hate the book, but I don't reread it either.

[Amanda N]

Like I said, when I read it, quite a few years had passed since I had read any of the previous books, so I don't remember.

[Eimi]

Yeah, I seem to remember thinking it wasn't bad.  It wasn't a "Skies of Pern" or anything, that's for sure!

[emma]

I dind't think it was then bad... But then I own 'To sail beyond the sunset' ;)

[Dana]

It wasn't bad    And yeah, Eimi, it definitely wasn't a "Skies"...although there were parts of "Skies" that I really enjoyed!